Add Your Review
Thanks for visiting New York Deli. We'd love to have your feedback!
Our Latest Reviews
This was my first time ordering from this restaurant and it was really hard to choose - everything looked so good! I finally decided on the BLT and it was AMAZING! All of the ingredients were so fresh and delicious. I can't wait to order again soon! =)
One of the best paninis I've had in a while! Also paired it with the red skin potato salad and it was fantastic!
Fresh and delicious!
Once again....the New York Deli of Appleton does it again! My New Yorker was money, my wife's turkey sub was amazing, and my son finished his grilled cheese as fast as I gave it to him! Absolutely love this place and the staff is always so kind! You all rock!!! Thanks again!!
The best cheesecake I have ever tasted!!
The Mediterranean wrap is amazing! I order it every time because i can't get enough of it. My favorite wrap ever!
Freaking delicious sandwich!! So good, will be back!
The Orange Ginger Chicken Salad is amazing. The sweetness of the oranges and the dressing are to die for! Your taste buds will thank you for picking this salad!
I first visited this place in 2016 during a construction job off casaloma drive, after the first time i was hooked from then till now if im in the area during operating hours i will always go and pick it a premium quality sandwich 🥪 😀 😉
This tuna melt is amazing. From the crunch of the bread to the soft tuna center it's everything you want in a tuna melt. Such good taste!
It's hard to choose a favorite sandwich, because they are all so good, but this is the one I come back to every time. It is consistently delicious. The perfect amount of everything and the spicy mayo (I think it's chipotle lime, or something along those lines) gives it the perfect kick. Truly the perfect sandwich!
Love this wrap. It is always a favorite, fresh and satisfying. Great flavor.
I stopped in to place a to go order today and had the best service and most delicious sandwich! My kiddo doesn't eat bread, and the gal who helped me was so accommodating by slicing him up some ham for his non-sandwich deli lunch. During this time it was also extremely refreshing to see that all the employees were wearing masks. I can not recommend New York Deli enough. Great People, Great Service, and Great Food!
Boars Head meat is the best. Unique menu and amazing staff.
Love New York Deli. They get the extra Kraut right each time! Great place to eat and have a lunch meeting.
This is hands down my favorite sandwich/wrap in the Fox Valley area. Quality ingredients and a delicious wrap!!
This Reuben was by far the most exquisite hot sandwich I've had in the fox valley. Thank you for providing this incredible indulgence.
I felt like I could have been in New York City itself! Minus the angry traffic, surly people, and city stench, of course. Try this sandwich if you haven't already. It's a taste of New York ... without having to be in New York.
This panini is consistently delicious and my favorite of all the delicious items on the menu! The bread is grilled just enough to be a little crunchy, the chicken is warm and tasty, the cheesy is melty and gooey, and the roasted veggies and basil pesto mayo add just the right zest. Always yummy!
Love this this restaurant! Great sandwiches with Boars Head meat. And they have the best carrot cake.
The wrap was excellent and served exactly as pictured! Very flavorful and filling as well. Will definitely be coming back to try more. Loved to see them taking the COVID-19 precautions seriously. Ordered online which was simple and they did curbside pick-up. Brought it out to my car within a minute of calling to notify I was there.
Delicious! Would eat this on a weekly basis
My favorite sandwich is a Reuben. I've had them all over the state. New York Deli has the best Reuben sandwich I have ever eaten. The balance of ingredients is perfect. Always thought I should try something different but ended up ordering the Reuben.
Wow. This place is amazing. I have consistently been blown away every time I eat here. The sandwiches really are something special. I highly recommend the Bronx Bomber, although every sandwich I've ever had is 10/10.
This place is amazing! I always get the Turkey Apple wrap and a iced coffee. They have many options to choose from though. Staff is alway friendly, and fun atmosphere.
Got the Tribeca Club on Gluten Free bread! So grateful for a delicious and healthy lunch to meet my gluten free needs! Highly Recommend!
This is the finest sandwich place in the entire Fox Valley. High quality Ingredients and a great staff serving them.
I love this wrap! I go there at least once a week and it is always my go-to lunch! Best service and food!
Awesome sandwich, super fresh and filling! You can see and taste the quality of the meat.
First time I have ever been-It was delicious! Highly recommend.
Best sandwich ever!!! Soooo delicious!
I LOVE this sandwich! Refreshing with the avocado but spicy with the mayo. A great take on an old classic.
My wife and I love this place. Our sandwiches are always amazing. One of our favorite places to stop for lunch!
This was amazingly delicious 😋 it didn't need the side of dressing! Love it 😍
This place is amazing! Best sandwiches in town and deli meats to make them yourself at home!
I love this place first of all. Everything I've ever had here is amazing! So fresh and tasty, you can never go wrong here!
Honestly haven't had a sandwich my wife and I didn't love but we always get the meatball sub to share. So good.
Love this sandwich. So much better than fast food. Fresh, warm, and tasty.
PAST DRAWING WINNERS
Costa Mesa, CA
Carol, Stroud's BBQ
Daytona Beach Shores, FL
Jo-El, Mick's All American
Mount Joy, PA
Bronson, Los Dos Potrillos
Elish, Crump's Landing
Carlson, Papi Grande's Mexican
Sommer, Little Calf Creamery
Thousand Oaks, CA
Theresa, Woody's Crab House
North East, MD
Maria, The Rustik Fork
Marsha, Stefano's Restaurant
Alma, Karai Ramen Bistro
Courtney, Axe & Arrow
Andy, Backwoods Brewing Co.
Amanda, Home Restaurant
Los Angeles, CA
Jennifer, Mark's City Grill
Rebecca, Frank Gourmet
Donna, Dino's Sports Bar
Cape Cod, MA
Karen, This Little Pig
Alicia, Plant Based Pizzeria